
* =Derby Record
# =Grand Prize Winner
| Year | Area | Name | Town | Weight | |
| 1996 | |||||
| Bluefish | (shore): | Dennis Williams | 18.47 | ||
| (boat): | Donald Ballou | 18.80 | |||
| Bonito | (shore): | John Livingston | 9.42 | ||
| (boat): | Perry C. Ambulos | 10.14 | |||
| Albacore | (shore): | Philip B. Willoughby | 11.68 | # | |
| (boat): | Arthur N. Vose | 11.97 | |||
| Bass | (shore): | Marke Plante | 47.37 | ||
| (boat): | Frank Nuovo | 49.11 | |||
| 1999 | |||||
| Bluefish | (shore): | Paul B. Schultz | 14.92 | ||
| (boat): | John Cowart | 17.31 | |||
| Bonito | (shore): | David Desmarais | 10.33 | # | |
| (boat): | Robert Mocarski | 10.77 | |||
| Albacore | (shore): | Dave Desmarais | 14.30 | ||
| (boat): | Lev Wlodyka | 12.05 | |||
| Bass | (shore): | William DeBettencourt | 42.27 | ||
| (boat): | Jen Clarke | 44.08 | |||
| 2000 | |||||
| Bluefish | (shore): | Kevin Hearn | 14.57 | ||
| (boat): | Joe Uva | 19.18 | |||
| Bonito | (shore): | Eric R. Wolfe | 7.11 | ||
| (boat): | Mark Plante | 10.37 | # | ||
| Albacore | (shore): | David Skok | 12.96 | ||
| (boat): | John Schillinger | 12.67 | |||
| Bass | (shore): | Stephen Morris | 41.78 | ||
| (boat): | Lev Wlodyka | 52.32 |